Hi Charles -
I agree with the excellent posts from Scott, Jim, and Nick. (And they also give you a sense of the technical discussions we have on the ACES committee.)
However keep in mind that the gamma adjustment factor Scott mentioned (to compensate for the surround difference) is less than 2%. In your case this is overwhelmed by the fact that the Rec.709 Output Transforms (ODTs) you’re using are intended for 2.4 gamma and it sounds like you’re looking at it on devices that are either calibrated to 2.2 or sRGB.
BT.1886 is essentially a 2.4 gamma, sitting on top of the device black. If you are mastering for traditional Rec.709 video delivery, then this is what you should be using. The standard for web delivery is sRGB (which is also called “RGB Monitor” in the ACES transform collection). You also mentioned YouTube and that one is harder to specify since people watch it both in web browsers and on smart TVs. It would be interesting to hear from the community what gamma people feel works best when mastering for YouTube (I’m guessing web is still the best choice).
To sum up, the practical advice I would give is as follows:
-
Calibrate your devices according to the delivery format you are mastering for. (ACES cannot help you with this part.) Use BT.1886 (essentially gamma 2.4) for TV and sRGB for web. Note that sRGB is very different from gamma 2.2 in the shadows and the ACES transforms really use the sRGB curve, not 2.2.
-
Choose the Rec.709 Output Transforms when mastering for TV and the “RGB Monitor” (or sRGB) Output Transform when mastering for web.
-
Choose the “D60 sim” flavor of Output Transform if you want to preserve the native cinema D60 whitepoint in your video deliverable, or choose the other flavor (without “D60 sim” in the name) to adapt D60 to D65 so that it will sit more comfortably with standard TV or computer content (e.g. commercials, computer user interfaces, etc.).
Hope that helps,
Doug Walker
Autodesk